Afternoon Tea at Alice’s Tea Cup

September 18, 2014 (Last Updated: January 3, 2020)
This post may contain affiliate links, which means that I may receive a commission if you make a purchase using these links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
a three-tiered afternoon tea display of food with a woman on the other side

Tea is my thing. I love it hot or iced year round, whether I brew a pot in my kitchen on a cold winter’s day, or meet a close friend for afternoon tea in the girliest of girly tea shops. The ultimate girly tea shop is undoubtedly Alice’s Tea Cup in New York City. There are three different locations throughout the city, each with slight differences in their menus.

A sign on the side of a building that says Alice\'s Tea Cup

The location I frequent is located on the Upper East Side on 64th Street. It’s a truly popular brunch destination, and thus does not offer reservations on weekends unless you have a party of six or more. I waited about 45 to 50 minutes for a table for two and arrived prior to 11:30 am on a Saturday.

A blackboard sign that says Scones of the Day with a list of flavors

The space if very whimsical. Little girls are offered sparkly fair wings and a dusting of glitter before heading to their tables. Alice’s Tea Cup is not only perfect for little girls, but big girls as well.

butterfly wing decorations on a turquoise ceiling

There was actually a baby shower being hosted in a back room during my recent visit. This is a very popular spot for occasions of that nature, and I’d love to host an event there as well if given the opportunity.

A closeup of a store display of scones

Every time I visit Alice’s Tea Cup I can’t resist indulging in one of their afternoon tea options. I’ve never ordered anything else, but since the afternoon tea comes with a variety of choices for each component, you can easily visit multiple times and still have a unique experience. And don’t get me started on the tea menu! It’s extensive and fills an entire book.

A teacup and saucer on a colorful table

If you chose afternoon tea at Alice’s Tea Cup, you have three options: The Nibble, The Mad Hatter, and The Jabberwocky. The portions and prices increase progressively. The Mad Hatter is perfect for two, and that’s what I’ve ordered on each occasion I’ve been here. If ordering for two, it comes with two pots of tea, three scones, two sandwiches, cookies, and a choice of dessert.

a sandwich on a plate next to a blue teapot and white teacup filled with tea

The teas we selected to try included the Indian Chai (prepared with the perfect amount of milk) and Symphony, which features a blend of strawberry and chocolate tea. The chai was truly the perfect combination of spices with just the right amount of milk. The Symphony was aptly named and created a wonderful balance of two flavors that really go hand in hand. The aroma is intense, and the flavor sublime.

a plate of three scones with small cups of butter and cream
Ham and cheese scone, mixed berry scone, and chocolate chip cranberry scone served with raspberry preserves, whipped cream, and clotted cream

Onto the food! The top tier of our assortment of treats contains three scones. We started with a savory scone, the ham and cheese. It’s super flaky and buttery. I love the chunks of ham and the sharp cheese in each bite. A little bit of clotted cream makes this scone even more decadent.

a closeup of a savory scone with cheese in it
Ham and cheese scone
a scone broken apart on a plate

We also selected a mixed berry scone and a chocolate chip cranberry scone. Both were delicious, but as a chocoholic, the chocolate-cranberry one was my favorite of the two. It should be noted that even sharing a Mad Hatter between two people, there is so much food that you will likely have leftovers. We definitely saved one of the three scones for snacking later on.

A close up of a half eaten scone in someone\'s hand
Chocolate chip cranberry scone with a schmear of raspberry preserves and cream

For sandwiches we picked the Chopped Tea-Egg Salad which features eggs that have been infused with tea and served on seven grain bread with watercress. This is a milder sandwich than some of the more assertive ones on the menu I’ve tried.

a variety of sandwich halves on a white plate

It’s a good option for a meatless sandwich, and one we picked to balance out our meal since our other sandwich was more intense in flavor. It was a pretty good egg salad, but didn’t really live up to some of the more creative choices on the menu.

A close up of a sandwich on a plate
Chopped-Tea Egg Salad

One of my favorite sandwiches–and one I’ve had here before–is the Curried Chicken Salad which is served on Golden Raisin Semolina bread from Amy’s Bread (in fact, I believe Amy’s provides all the bread for the menu; they are exceptional!). This is a much more flavorful option compared to the Egg Salad, and our definite favorite of the two.

A sandwich cut in half on a plate
Curried Chicken Salad

Finally, it’s time for sweets. Between our choices of Mocha Cake, Lemon Tart, or Chocolate Mousse, we went with the Lemon Tart because my friend is OBSESSED with lemon desserts, and well, I love them too! It was a tiny little tart but it packed a bright and intense citrus flavor. Along with a variety of small cookies, this is a lovely sweet finish to finish up that pot of tea.

a plate of cookies and a small cream topped tart
Lemon tart and cookies

Alice’s Tea Cup is a perennial favorite in a city with literally thousands of options at any given time. It’s more than a meal, it’s really an experience. Although the food is very good, I’ve had some hit or miss moments between a too sweet pumpkin scone on a previous visit, to a good-but-not-great egg salad sandwich.

A woman looking at the camera in between tiered plates of food

If you’re a foodie, you will find better sandwiches in general elsewhere in this gastronomically diverse city. As a package in terms of afternoon tea, where each component coexists with the others to create this delectable experience, and additionally is served with exceptional teas in any variety you can dream, Alice’s Tea Cup is the place to be.

A woman taking a photo of a cup and saucer on a table

Alice’s Tea Cup 
156 E 64th St (plus 2 other locations)
(between Lexington Ave & 3rd Ave)
New York, NY 10021
(212) 486-9200

No Comments

Leave a Reply