The perfect summertime antipasti, Insalata Caprese or Caprese Salad is as simple as it gets. Featuring fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, basil, and extra-virgin olive oil, it’s the ultimate ode to summer.
8ouncesfresh mozzarellapreferably buffalo mozzarella if you can find it
10fresh basil leavesor more as desired
1tablespoonextra-virgin olive oiluse the best quality you can
Kosher or flaky sea saltI use fleur de sel
Freshly ground black pepperoptional
Dried oreganooptional
Instructions
Place the tomatoes on a cutting board with the stem facing to the side. Slice into ¼-inch-thick slices with a sharp knife. You can discard or snack on the bottom and top pieces.
Drain the mozzarella and lightly pat it dry. Slice into ¼-inch-thick slices with a sharp knife.
Arrange the slices of tomato and mozzarella on a platter. You can alternate the slices or be a bit more rustic in your arrangement. Tuck some basil leaves in between or scatter them on top.
Drizzle the extra-virgin olive oil over the top and season with salt. If desired, also season with freshly ground black pepper and/or dried oregano. Serve immediately.
Notes
The calculated nutritional information here uses buffalo mozzarella which has a higher fat content than cow's milk mozzarella. If you use cow's milk mozzarella, the nutritional info would be different.
Tomatoes: For a recipe with so few ingredients, it’s really important that each one is the best you can get. Ideally, use fresh summer tomatoes. The number of tomatoes you use will really depend on their size and the thickness of the slices. Plan to only use the middle slices of each tomato, setting aside the bottom and top pieces for snacking. I used 2 beefsteak tomatoes (minus their tops and bottoms) each weighing about 9 ounces.
Mozzarella: Use a ball of fresh mozzarella cheese. Packed in water is preferable to cryo-sealed but either will work. Again, use the best quality you can. If you can find fresh buffalo mozzarella (made from the milk of Italian water buffalo), get it! It’s richer and creamier. You can really taste the difference not only in the cheese itself but in your finished insalata caprese. I got my Italian buffalo mozzarella from Venda Ravioli in Providence, RI. This imported 8.8-ounce ball was significantly pricier than your typical supermarket cow’s milk mozzarella (around $15 vs $5) but totally worth it IMO! I have also tried Buf Creamery Ovoline buffalo mozzarella, which is a 7-ounce ball priced around $11 at Whole Foods. This is made with milk from Colombian water buffalos. It's also a very good option if you can't get one imported from Italy.
Fresh Basil: Only fresh basil will do, not dried.
Extra-Virgin Olive Oil: I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, for a recipe as simple as this you really need each ingredient to shine. Use the best quality extra-virgin olive oil you can.
No Vinegar in Caprese Salad!: Authentic caprese salad in Italy does NOT use balsamic vinegar. The inclusion of balsamic vinegar in Americanized versions stems from using lower quality ingredients (perhaps off-season tomatoes and mediocre quality mozzarella) in order to add more flavor to the dish. If you use really good quality ingredients, they will already have wonderful flavor without covering them up with vinegar.